Shenzhen JDT Fuse Industrial Co.,Ltd

Phone : 0755-8830-8258

Postcode : 518129

E-Mail : andyzheng@jdtfuse.com

URL : http://www.joincircuit.com/

Ceramic PTC vs Organic PTC Performance

Thermistors have been widely used in recent years in the subscriber line interface circuits of program-controlled switching systems, where they guard against high-voltage lightning surges and AC mains contact. As a newer type of overcurrent protection device, thermistors divide by material into ceramic PTCs and organic PTCs, so this article gathers the similarities and differences between the two for reference.
 
 
Organic PTC: Key Points:
 
 
Working principle: an organic PTC is a polymer compound blended with carbon powder and formed by extrusion. The carbon powder forms conductive carbon chains; when it is heated, the polymer expands, the chains break and the device enters a high-resistance state that protects the circuit. (Related reading: PPTC Overview)
 
 
Advantages: the zero-power resistance at room temperature can be made quite low, which suits series connection in high-current power circuits for overcurrent protection or as a thermal fuse; resistance transitions quickly, heat capacity is small and recovery time is short.
 
 
Disadvantages: because of the polymer material and its structural mechanism, resistance rises after every overcurrent surge and does not return to its original value, and the outer encapsulation can crack under high-voltage, high-current pulse surges.
 
 
Ceramic PTC: Key Points:
 
 
Composition: mainly barium titanate powder with a positive temperature coefficient, sintered at high temperature by an electronic ceramic process.
 
 
Advantages: easy to manufacture and relatively inexpensive.
 
 
Disadvantages: high resistance, large size and high in-circuit loss, in the range of tens to thousands of Ω, so it suits low-current overcurrent protection only. In high-temperature overheating it can show a negative resistance effect (resistance drops), protection is slow, on the order of hundreds of ms, heat capacity is large and recovery takes longer.
 
 
The comparison above gives a general picture of ceramic PTC (resettable fuse) and organic PTC performance. One more point on a common misconception: many people believe an organic PTC responds faster and trips sooner than a ceramic PTC. That is not necessarily so.
 
 
Trip time of a PTC falls into two stages: the initial overcurrent preheating and temperature build-up time T1, and the abrupt resistance change time T2 after the temperature passes the Curie point. For an organic PTC the time T2 for resistance to climb from a few ohms to a few kilohms is on the order of ms, while T2 of a ceramic PTC is longer, on the order of tens of ms; in the T1 stage, however, a ceramic PTC has the smaller T1.
 
 
Total time is therefore T = T1 + T2. When the surge current through the PTC is relatively small, the total trip time of a ceramic PTC is shorter than that of an organic PTC, and the ceramic part also gives better low-current protection. (Recommended reading: What a PTC Is and How a PTC Works)
 
 
So ceramic and organic PTCs each have their own strengths, and in any circuit the right choice is simply what fits. In practice, switching systems widely use domestically made ceramic PTCs to replace expensive organic PTCs, which lowers production cost and improves economic returns while also supporting the domestic PTC industry, with a positive social effect as well.