Questions of this kind keep coming up online, so let us look at how fuses and fusible resistors should be chosen, starting with one reader's question.
A reader posting as “February” asks: I would appreciate some expert advice. We build power adapters, and on some models we used a fusible resistor instead of a fuse. When the customer received the units, however, they questioned why there was no fuse, because we had substituted a fusible resistor. We explained it at length and they were still not convinced! So which is better, a fuse or a fusible resistor?
A reader from Shanxi, posting as “Moxian Nuan”, answers: fusible resistors and fuses play different roles in a circuit. A fusible resistor is a low-resistance current-limiting protective component that provides overload protection and eventually opens; a fuse is a near-zero-resistance short-circuit protective device. The first responds gradually, the second instantaneously. Neither can replace the other.
A reader from Zhanjiang, Guangdong, posting as “cfraih”, answers: a fusible resistor is somewhat better, in my experience. (Related reading: types of fuses)
A reader from Guangzhou, Guangdong, posting as “sfetret”, replies: I have no idea either. Could somebody with experience shed some light on this? I would like to learn too.
A reader from Huangshi, Hubei, posting as “tiffly”, replies: they are the same, there is no real difference. A resistor and a fuse work on the same principle, and when the circuit fails and an overload develops, it opens. Whether an adapter or a charger uses a fuse or a fusible resistor, once it burns out the unit is scrap, so it makes no difference which one is used. As a consumer who is no expert, my opinion may well be wrong, and I would welcome corrections.
A specialist from Shenzhen Joincircuit Industrial Co., Ltd. answers: a fuse opens when the current becomes excessive, and in that way protects the circuit. A fusible resistor divides the voltage and limits the current; it is normally connected in series with the load, so that a failed appliance cannot short the circuit. It serves a protective purpose as well.
Once a fuse has opened it has to be replaced. A fusible resistor does not open; its main job is to prevent short circuits, which are dangerous and can start a fire. How large a resistance to use depends on the actual application: too high a value wastes a lot of power in the resistor itself.
The answers above are collected from the web, together with the explanation provided by Joincircuit. For more on fuses, please consult our online sales staff or read the other articles on this site. (Recommended reading: 30 V radial-leaded resettable fuse A30)